Challenging An Unfair Divorce Settlement In California
A divorce settlement may be unfair if one spouse hid important assets, provided false information, or pressured the other into agreeing. In these situations, California law may allow you to set aside the judgment.
But just regretting the settlement or believing you could have received a better deal is not enough. Family Code sections 2120 through 2129 set specific grounds for challenging a judgment, including fraud, perjury, duress, mistake, mental incapacity, and failure to disclose assets.
These claims also have strict deadlines. This guide explains when you may be able to challenge a divorce settlement and what you need to know before taking action.
What Are The Grounds And Deadlines?
Each reason for setting aside a judgment has its own deadline. Missing the deadline can prevent you from bringing the challenge.
|
Reason |
Deadline |
| Fraud | 1 year after discovering, or when you should have discovered, the fraud |
| Perjury | 1 year after discovering, or when you should have discovered, the perjury |
| Duress | 2 years after the judgment |
| Mental incapacity | 2 years after the judgment |
| Mistake in a stipulated or uncontested judgment | 1 year after the judgment |
| Failure to follow disclosure rules | 1 year after discovering, or when you should have discovered, the problem |
For fraud, perjury, and failure to disclose information, the clock can start when you discover the problem. But you cannot simply wait after having enough information to know something may be wrong.
What If Your Spouse Hid Assets?
Hidden assets can give you a strong reason to challenge a divorce settlement. California requires spouses to fully disclose their assets and debts during a divorce.
For example, a spouse may fail to disclose a bank account, business interest, bonus, or property. If that information was hidden during the divorce, it may affect how the property was divided.
In In re Marriage of Rossi, a wife failed to disclose $1.3 million in lottery winnings during the divorce. After the money was discovered, the court awarded the husband 100% of the winnings because of how the asset was hidden.
So if your settlement now looks very different because you found an asset that was never disclosed, the disclosure rules may matter.
What Does It Take To Challenge A Divorce Settlement?
Challenging a divorce settlement takes more than showing that the agreement was unfair. You need to show that a specific problem affected the judgment and that you are still within the time allowed by California law.
A few things matter when preparing a challenge:
- Know the reason: Identify whether the issue involves fraud, hidden assets, duress, perjury, mistake, or another ground allowed by law.
- Check the deadline: Each ground has its own deadline, so find out when the time limit started and whether it has passed.
- Gather evidence: Financial records, messages, emails, court documents, and other records may help show what happened.
- Show how it mattered: You need to explain how the problem affected the settlement or judgment.
- Act quickly: If you discover a hidden asset or other problem, keep records of when you found out and take action promptly.
- Know what may change: The court may change only the part of the judgment affected by the problem rather than reopen the entire divorce.
The California divorce process can help explain how a divorce judgment is reached and what happens before a post-judgment challenge.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I reopen my divorce because I got a bad settlement?
Not by itself. You need a specific legal reason, such as fraud, duress, perjury, certain mistakes, or failure to disclose assets or debts.
What if my ex hid money during the divorce?
Hidden assets can be a reason to challenge the judgment. California requires spouses to disclose their assets and debts, and serious concealment can lead to major changes in the property division.
How long do I have to challenge the judgment?
It depends on the reason. Some claims have a one-year deadline, while duress and mental incapacity have a two-year deadline. Discovery-based claims can run from when you knew or should have known about the problem.
Will the entire divorce be reopened?
Not necessarily. The court may change only the part of the judgment affected by the problem, such as the division of property. See our page on modifying court orders for related post-judgment issues.
Conclusion
If you think your divorce settlement was unfair, the reason behind it matters. A change of heart is not enough, but hidden assets, fraud, pressure, or other problems with the settlement may give you a way to challenge the judgment.
The deadlines can be short, especially when you are challenging something you discovered after the divorce. If you think your former spouse left out important information or you were pressured into the agreement, Pedrick Law Group can look at what happened and tell you whether you may be able to challenge the judgment.
The firm handles divorce and post-judgment matters across Encino and Orange County, and Gregory J. Pedrick is a certified family law specialist through the California Board of Legal Specialization.